I-3-4-5. No Right to Request Review

Last Update: 9/08/05 (Transmittal I-3-36)

A. General

The Appeals Council may dismiss a request for review when the request for review is filed by a person who is not a proper party.

NOTE:

See I-3-4-6 for procedures when the request for review is either prematurely filed or erroneously prepared.

B. Operating Procedure

1. No Proper Party

The Appeals Council may dismiss a request for review if the individual filing the request is not a proper party or does not otherwise have a right to request review. In most cases, a proper party is the person who received the hearing decision or dismissal; however, persons whose rights may be adversely affected by a decision may be parties to the case and thus have the right to file a request for review. (20 CFR 404.932 and 416.1432.)

Also, the following persons may file a request for review on behalf of a party:

C. Preparing Recommendation to the Appeals Council

  1. If the request for review is filed by a proper party and is otherwise appropriate, proceed to consider the case on its merits (see I-3-1, Workup of Case by Analyst).

  2. If the request for review was not filed by a proper party, the analyst will prepare a memorandum or analysis (no standard form required) explaining the relevant factors in the case; i.e., why there is no right to request review. The analyst will also prepare an appropriate dismissal order. See Appeals Text Guide.