Description of Proposed Provision:
B5.8: Beginning in 2022, create a Basic Minimum Benefit (BMB) within Social Security (i.e., the cost of the BMB would be charged as a cost to the OASI Trust Fund), with the following specifications: (1) Eligibility for the BMB would be limited to OASI beneficiaries who have attained normal retirement age (NRA) or above. OASI beneficiaries under NRA would not be eligible for the BMB. (2) The BMB would be calculated on a household basis and split equally between members of the household. In the case of a married couple, both spouses would need to claim any Social Security benefits for which they are eligible before they could receive the BMB. If both spouses have claimed and one is NRA or above and the other has not yet attained NRA, only the half of the BMB for the spouse over NRA would be payable. (3) The BMB amount for single beneficiaries would be equal to either: 1) the BMB base ($604 in 2015) - 0.70 * current monthly OASI benefit (not including any BMB), if positive; or 2) zero. (4) The BMB amount for married beneficiaries would be equal to either: 1) the BMB base ($906 in 2015) - 0.70 * total household monthly OASI benefits (not including any BMB), if positive; or 2) zero. (5) The BMB bases for singles and couples would be updated annually for changes in the average wage index (AWI). (6) Single filers with Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) over $30,000 and joint filers with AGI (including taxable SS benefits) over $45,000 would be subject to clawback of the BMB through the income tax system. Any BMB would be reduced by one dollar for every dollar of income above the thresholds. (Thresholds, in 2015 dollars, would be indexed to chained CPI-U.) Clawbacks would be credited back to the OASI Trust Fund.

Financial Estimates for the OASDI Trust Fund Program

  Proposal   Change from Current Law
  Expressed as a percentage of
current-law taxable payroll

Trust fund
ratio as of
January 1
Expressed as a percentage of
current-law taxable payroll
Calendar
year
Cost
rate
Income
rate
Annual
balance

Cost
rate
Income
rate
Annual
balance
201713.4113.03-0.38
298
0.000.000.00
201813.4912.93-0.56
287
0.000.000.00
201913.7012.95-0.75
273
0.000.000.00
202013.8512.96-0.89
259
0.000.000.00
202114.0212.99-1.03
245
0.000.000.00
202214.3913.03-1.36
228
0.130.01-0.13
202314.6813.06-1.63
212
0.140.01-0.13
202414.9713.09-1.88
195
0.140.01-0.13
202515.2513.11-2.14
178
0.150.01-0.14
202615.5213.14-2.38
160
0.150.01-0.14
202715.7713.16-2.61
142
0.160.01-0.15
202816.0213.18-2.84
124
0.160.01-0.15
202916.2413.19-3.04
105
0.170.01-0.16
203016.4413.21-3.24
86
0.180.01-0.17
203116.6313.22-3.41
67
0.180.01-0.17
203216.7913.23-3.56
47
0.190.01-0.18
203316.9313.24-3.69
27
0.190.01-0.18
203417.0413.25-3.80
5
0.200.01-0.18
203517.1313.25-3.88
----
0.200.01-0.19
203617.1913.26-3.93
----
0.200.01-0.19
203717.2313.26-3.97
----
0.210.01-0.19
203817.2313.26-3.97
----
0.210.01-0.20
203917.2113.26-3.95
----
0.210.01-0.20
204017.1813.26-3.92
----
0.220.01-0.20
204117.1313.26-3.87
----
0.220.01-0.20
204217.0813.26-3.82
----
0.220.01-0.21
204317.0313.25-3.77
----
0.220.01-0.21
204416.9813.25-3.73
----
0.220.01-0.21
204516.9413.25-3.69
----
0.220.01-0.21
204616.9013.25-3.66
----
0.220.01-0.21
204716.8713.25-3.62
----
0.230.01-0.21
204816.8413.25-3.60
----
0.230.01-0.22
204916.8213.25-3.57
----
0.230.01-0.22
205016.8013.24-3.55
----
0.230.01-0.22
205116.7913.25-3.54
----
0.230.01-0.22
205216.7913.25-3.55
----
0.240.01-0.22
205316.8113.25-3.56
----
0.240.01-0.23
205416.8313.25-3.58
----
0.240.01-0.23
205516.8613.25-3.61
----
0.240.01-0.23
205616.9013.25-3.65
----
0.250.01-0.23
205716.9513.26-3.69
----
0.250.01-0.24
205816.9913.26-3.73
----
0.250.01-0.24
205917.0413.26-3.77
----
0.250.01-0.24
206017.0813.27-3.81
----
0.250.01-0.24
206117.1313.27-3.86
----
0.250.01-0.24
206217.1813.27-3.90
----
0.250.01-0.24
206317.2213.28-3.95
----
0.250.01-0.24
206417.2713.28-3.99
----
0.250.01-0.24
206517.3213.28-4.04
----
0.260.01-0.24
206617.3713.29-4.09
----
0.260.01-0.24
206717.4313.29-4.14
----
0.260.01-0.24
206817.4813.29-4.19
----
0.260.01-0.24
206917.5313.30-4.24
----
0.260.01-0.24
207017.5813.30-4.28
----
0.260.01-0.24
207117.6313.30-4.33
----
0.260.01-0.24
207217.6713.31-4.37
----
0.260.01-0.24
207317.7113.31-4.40
----
0.260.01-0.24
207417.7413.31-4.43
----
0.260.01-0.24
207517.7613.31-4.45
----
0.260.01-0.24
207617.7813.31-4.47
----
0.260.01-0.24
207717.7813.31-4.47
----
0.260.01-0.24
207817.7813.31-4.47
----
0.260.01-0.24
207917.7813.31-4.46
----
0.260.01-0.24
208017.7713.31-4.46
----
0.260.01-0.24
208117.7613.31-4.45
----
0.260.01-0.24
208217.7613.31-4.45
----
0.260.01-0.24
208317.7713.31-4.46
----
0.250.01-0.24
208417.7813.31-4.47
----
0.250.01-0.24
208517.8013.31-4.49
----
0.250.01-0.24
208617.8313.32-4.52
----
0.250.01-0.24
208717.8713.32-4.55
----
0.250.01-0.24
208817.9113.32-4.59
----
0.250.01-0.24
208917.9513.32-4.63
----
0.250.01-0.24
209018.0013.33-4.68
----
0.250.01-0.24
209118.0513.33-4.72
----
0.250.01-0.24
209218.1013.33-4.77
----
0.250.01-0.24


Summarized Estimates

  Proposal   Change from Current Law
Years Cost
rate
Income
rate
Actuarial
balance

Year of reserve
depletion
1

Cost
rate
Income
rate
Actuarial
balance
2017-2091 16.87% 13.85% -3.02%
2034
0.21% 0.01% -0.20%

1 Under current law, the year of Trust Fund reserve depletion is 2034.
Based on Intermediate Assumptions of the 2017 Trustees Report.